A Sleep Apnea Mystery Solved?

Dr. Bradley was puzzled.  These patients with heart and kidney failure often had something else in common.  Sleep apnea.  Why?

In the most recent edition of HeadWay, we were exploring the connection between sleep apnea (or sleep apnoea) and migraine, headaches and cluster headache.  There’s good evidence for a strong relationship.  It seems many people with headache and migraine also have sleep apnea, and we know that sleep patterns are closely related to an increase in these other attacks.

Sleep apnea - new treatment options?

Sleep apnea interrupts sleep, and can make you drowsy during the day.  It can also lead to serious heart problems and diabetes.

But the underlying cause of sleep apnea is not easy to explain.  We know that, for example, obesity is a risk factor.  But many people with sleep apnea are not obese, and are otherwise fairly healthy.  So what’s the problem?

Dr. Douglas Bradley, who we mentioned earlier, noticed that his patients did have something else in common.  Fluid retention (oedema).

Could fluid retention be causing the sleep apnea?

Dr. Bradley and his team set out to study 23 non-obese men.  When these men got horizontal to sleep, the fluid shifted in their bodies, and the circumference of their necks actually increased.  For the control group, it was an increase of 1/2 a centimetre.  But for those with sleep apnea, it was double that, 1 centimetre.  Why?  You guessed it.  Fluid.

So what’s happening?  Dr Bradley explains:

Gravity forces fluid down to the bottom of the body when you are sitting and your legs are inactive.  Standing and walking cause the calf muscles to contract, pumping fluid from the legs up through the veins toward the heart.

When you lie down to sleep, that "extra" fluid gets redistributed, causing the increase in neck circumference, which may be causing blockage leading to some sleep apnea.  (Read the story at Groundbreaking study results could help reduce the incidence of obstructive sleep apnea)

This surprising turn of events leads to some interesting treatments for sleep apnea, and so for the headaches it causes.

The first, best, and most obvious?  Move around!

If you tend to sit or even stand a lot of the day, try changing position, going for walks, getting your leg muscles working.  This keeps the fluid moving through your body the way it’s supposed to.

Dr. Bradley also suggests that elevating your upper body while you sleep may help, interestingly enough something that was recently discussed in a blog carnival entry Sleeping off my headache….

Other common treatments for fluid retention?  Don’t eat too much salt.  Drink plenty of water.  And how about this – one treatment for decreasing fluid retention that comes with the menstrual cycle is magnesium.  We keep coming back to that, don’t we?

One more interesting note.  Some drugs can increase fluid retention, such as NSAIDs (ie naproxen, oxaprozin and ibuprofen), and calcium channel and beta blockers, all commonly used for migraine, and often various types of headache.

Often sleep apnea is treated with special masks worn at night, implants, and even surgery.  But for many, this discovery may lead to solutions that are much less drastic.  And that means a lot less headaches.

Be Sociable, Share!
7 comments… add one
  • Kay Feb 23, 2009

    Very interesting. Thanks for sharing this.

    I suspect that I have sleep apnea. Both my parents have it. I’ll have to try the sleeping while propped up trick and see if it helps my daytime drowsiness (and headaches).

  • James Mar 5, 2009

    Thanks Kay! Let us know what you find out.

  • Chris Aug 25, 2009

    I think there is a possibility that I have sleep apnea. Seeing as how migraines have been linked to sleep apnea (I get migraines) and I feel generally tired throughout the day… I went through a nice period of not having migraines and I also note that I was sleeping decently then too. But now it sleeps I sometimes stop breathing and have constantly interrupted sleep which is especially disconcerting since I’m a student..

  • Nickie A Sep 3, 2009

    I have been diagnosed with sleep apnea along with my chronic resistant migraines. I had sleep oximetry study done in the hospital last week and they found that I stopped breathing every fourteen minutes. They found that because I kept stopping breathing my body was awakened to restart my breathing, preventing me from getting a good sleep.

    My doctor prescribed a CPAP machine and I’ve been using it ever since. I’ve woken up three out of five days without a migraine — a first for me in a long time.

    I’m also on a diuretic – to reduce fluid – because of congestive heart failure — suspected to be caused by DHE. Between the two I haven’t had a good sleep in a long time.

  • John Sep 9, 2009

    being a natural home remedies buff I found your article very interesting.
    It’s well known that the body retains more fluid during sleep but its a new idea that fluid retention can contribute or even cause sleep apnea.

  • Jennifer Jul 21, 2011

    The findings from this 5 year study re-iterate the advise offered here that increased movement and exercise help to address the complications of sleep apnea including migraines and high blood pressure.
    Do you have a link any studies regarding the association between NSAID’s and sleep disorders?

  • Moses Shuldiner Aug 26, 2012

    I have been diagnosed, in a sleep lab, with chronic obstructive sleep apnea. BUt it only occurs in the supine (lying on the back) position. A suggested remedy that I am trying is to attache a tennis ball to the back of my sleeping garment. This makes me, hopefully, move away from the supine position. So far I am sleeping better – not waking up with a headache, being woken by an alarm (i.e. from sleep) and feeling more refreshed on arising. How ironic if a lifelong condition can be treated with a $0.50 tennis ball, a scrap of cloth and a few safety pins.

Leave a Comment